On November 2, a 1948 two-bedroom on 5th Street in the Mira Costa area of East Manhattan Beach closed at $2,525,000. The house has one bath and 1,085 square feet, so the sale works out to $2,327 per square foot. That is above the $2,015 median for homes built since 2005 in the Manhattan Beach Sand Section, a figure South Bay agent Ed Kaminsky published in October from CRMLS sales between October 2024 and October 2026. The listing explains why in one line. The home sold off-market for land value, and it went into the MLS only so it could serve as a comparable sale.
The buyer paid $2.5 million for 7,503 square feet of land, and the 1,085-square-foot house came with it. If you compare Manhattan Beach sections by price per square foot, older homes will throw off your numbers for exactly this reason. The useful figures are a different pair: what a buildable lot trades for in each section, and what a finished new home on a lot that size closes at. The gap between the two is the real price of a new house here, and this fall it has been moving.
The lot is the price
Seven older homes that sold between September and early November 2026 show what land costs right now. Each one was marketed as a lot, a teardown or a chance to build new, or sold in original condition.
| Address | Area | Closed | Price | Lot size | Price per lot sq. ft. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1440 19th Street | Manhattan Heights / Liberty Village | Sept. 1, 2026 | $2,550,000 | 7,006 | about $364 |
| 2909 N. Valley Drive | Tree Section | Sept. 11, 2026 | $1,850,000 | 5,017 | about $369 |
| 1813 5th Street | Mira Costa, East Manhattan | Sept. 22, 2026 | $2,400,000 | 7,501 | about $320 |
| 3504 Walnut Avenue | Tree Section | Sept. 24, 2026 | $2,150,000 | 4,644 | about $463 |
| 426 S. Peck Avenue | Mira Costa, East Manhattan | Oct. 7, 2026 | $2,005,000 | 4,857 | about $413 |
| 1410 17th Street | Manhattan Heights / Liberty Village | Oct. 14, 2026 | $2,510,000 | 7,350 | about $341 |
| 1756 5th Street | Mira Costa, East Manhattan | Nov. 2, 2026 | $2,525,000 | 7,503 | about $336 |
The houses on these lots were built in 1912, 1948, 1949, 1952, 1958 and 1965, and none of those dates moved the price much. Lot size did. On the east side, the 7,000- to 7,500-square-foot lots on 5th, 17th and 19th Streets closed within $150,000 of each other, between $2.4 million and $2.55 million. One of the 17th Street listing's MLS fields lists "Tear Down" and "Value In Land." The 19th Street listing called the property a "starter home/development site."
The Tree Section has smaller lots that cost more per foot. The Valley Drive lot is 50 by 100 feet. It was listed July 1 at $1,999,000 and closed September 11 at $1,850,000. The listing called it the lowest-priced lot in the Tree Section, and it pitched builders on the fact that new Tree Section homes were selling around $6 million. A few blocks north, the 1912 house on Walnut sold in original condition for $2,150,000.
On the east side, then, land has cost roughly $320 to $365 per square foot of lot this fall. Tree Section land has run from about $370 to more than $460. A buyer comparing the two areas is comparing those land prices first.
What the finished house closes at
New builds in the same areas set the top of the range. In the Tree Section, 657 27th Street closed November 9 at $6,250,000. It has 3,361 square feet of interior space on a 4,800-square-foot lot. On September 30, 2316 Pine Avenue was recorded as a $5,765,000 off-market sale: a 3,551-square-foot home on a 4,481-square-foot lot, close in size to the Walnut and Valley parcels.
On the larger lots, 1013 10th Street closed November 13 at $8,200,000. It is a five-bedroom, 5,016-square-foot home on a 7,491-square-foot lot. Earlier in the year, 1525 10th Street in East Manhattan Beach closed at $6,325,000 for about 5,051 square feet, according to Kaminsky's write-up.
Put the two halves together and the gap is large and fairly steady. A Tree Section lot that trades around $2 million becomes a house that closes around $6 million. A 7,500-square-foot east side lot near $2.5 million becomes a house that has closed this year anywhere from about $6.3 million to $8.2 million, with others now listed as low as $5.25 million. Roughly $4 million on a Tree Section parcel, and more on many east side parcels, pays for demolition, design, permits, construction, carrying costs and the builder's margin. It also pays for time. Reeland Investments, a spec builder that lists six Manhattan Beach projects in development on Poinsettia Avenue, Pine Avenue, Marshallfield Lane, 18th Street, Curtis Avenue and 29th Street, puts a typical ground-up build here at 12 to 20 months from permit issuance.
So a buyer of a finished new home is paying the builder to carry more than a year of risk, often closer to two. A builder who bought a lot this fall is betting on what a finished house will sell for once that build is done.
Where that gap is being tested
The current new-construction inventory shows the bet doesn't always pay off at full asking price. As of November 15, a local MLS feed showed 12 new-construction homes for sale in Manhattan Beach.
On the larger east side lots, list prices cover a wide range for homes of nearly the same size. On the 7,500-square-foot lots, 1712 Ruhland Avenue had 4,982 square feet listed at $5,500,000 and 1827 9th Street had 4,956 square feet at $5,250,000. 1612 Gates Avenue, with 5,080 square feet on a 7,510-square-foot lot, was asking $5,899,000 after 308 days on market. Those prices sit far below the $8.2 million that 1013 10th Street closed at on November 13. Kaminsky's medians for homes built since 2005 tell the same story: $1,215 per square foot in Manhattan Heights and Liberty Village across 14 sales, against $1,483 in the Tree Section across 52, for closings between October 2024 and October 2026.
Kaminsky attributes a gap like that to build quality, finish level and how close a home sits to a busier street like Aviation Boulevard. For a buyer, the practical point is simpler. East side land costs nearly the same from lot to lot, and finished homes do not. Most of the difference between a $5.25 million asking price and an $8.2 million closing on similar east side dirt is the house.
Price cuts have reached the top of the range too. 1808 Laurel Avenue, a 4,720-square-foot home on a 4,800-square-foot lot, was listed at $8,629,000 on November 15, marked with a recent price cut and showing 46 days on market. Each of those day counts is a few days higher now.
Where an older, remodeled home fits
Most buyers in these sections aren't choosing between a bare lot and a brand-new house. They are looking at the homes in between, and the land math helps price those too.
On October 14, 3504 N. Poinsettia Avenue in the Tree Section closed at $3,050,000. It is a 1972 home remodeled in 2010, on a 4,640-square-foot lot. Tree Section lots of that size sold for $1.85 million to $2.15 million in September, so that remodel earned roughly $900,000 to $1.2 million above land. That is real value, and it still leaves the home about $3 million short of the $6.25 million that 657 27th Street closed at. New construction draws its own pool of buyers, with different expectations about materials and finish, and a remodeled 1970s home rarely gets priced like a new one per square foot.
That leaves a buyer comparing sections with three questions. What does the land under this house trade for right now? How much does the existing house add above that? And how far is this price from what a finished new home on a similar lot has actually closed for? A remodeled home priced near new-construction territory is being measured against the wrong comparable. When an older home is priced well above recent lot sales, the seller is counting on the house to carry value that the market may treat as a teardown.
Quick answers
Does a high price per square foot on an older Manhattan Beach home mean it's overpriced? Not necessarily. On a teardown-condition house, the figure mostly reflects the lot divided by a small interior. The 1948 house on 5th Street that sold for land value on November 2 came out to $2,327 per square foot. Comparing the price per square foot of the lot with recent lot sales in the same section gives a clearer read.
Is East Manhattan Beach land cheaper than Tree Section land? Per square foot of lot, it has been this fall. East side lots of 7,000 to 7,500 square feet sold at about $320 to $365 per lot square foot between September and November 2026. Tree Section lots ran about $370 to more than $460 over the same months. East side lots are larger, though, so the total price often comes out higher.
How long does a new home take to build here? One active local builder puts a typical ground-up build at 12 to 20 months from permit issuance. That timeline is part of the price gap between a lot sale and a finished-home sale.
If you're weighing an older home against a new build in the Tree Section or East Manhattan Beach, the first number to settle is what the lot under each one is worth today. When you're ready to talk through the blocks you're considering, reach out to Azure Hynes, or start with a home valuation if you're curious how land value shapes yours. Let's connect.